Today’s Difference Between Austin, TX and Brooklyn, NYMy
New York Times habit remains intact, but they do tend to pile up when I’m a bit busy. So I didn’t notice
this story until today.
Now, my feelings about the gentrification of Park Slope are complex and conflicted. Because, truth be told, I
loved the changes that I lived through once Asia and I moved below the 5th Avenue line. I loved having bars and restaurants and a record store I could walk to. All those tiny boutiques that sold things I’m sure some people must buy I could have done without, but starting with Great Lakes and moving forward to Al Di La, Convivium, and even Moutarde, I was happy with the expanding food and drink options. When Southpaw opened and the Key Food started devoting more space to foodie lovelies than Goya products, I was tickled.
But I was
guilty about being tickled (and I never embraced those annoying, arrogant over priced twats at Beercraft) because I understood that a vibrant community was being displaced to make way for the things that made me happy.
But, the thing is, the first wave of new businesses that came to Fifth Ave. weren’t really displacing much of anything. Those storefronts were vacant; that’s why the leases the first wave signed were both long term and cheap. Those of you still there are about to see what happens when the market corrects: Great Lakes, for example, has a ten year lease. It’s about up.
But, it took a while for the Fifth Avenue Expansion to make its way above Ninth Street. My old employer is connected with this trend, but one of the fantastic things about the Slope below Ninth Street is that most of the storefronts don’t have enough square footage to interest chain stores. The glaring exceptions to that are, of course, the Barnes and Ignoble and Starfucks on Seventh Ave. and a drugstore or two.
But there were options. You could get your books at the Community Bookstore. And, if you wanted bad coffee, Ozzie’s was there instead of Starfucks. Then, when Gorilla opened, you could actually get good coffee to go with your ideals. It all felt good.
Above Ninth, particularly on Fifth, there’s some serious square footage available, and I suspect the arrival of Dunkin’ Donuts is just a start, but it is portentous. D&D is pretty much the caffeinated expression of suburbia. I spent countless hours between the ages of 14 and 18 sucking down D&D coffee and cigarettes while bemoaning my small town (lack of) life. It is everything that moving to New York was supposed to erase.
Dee Dee Donuts, on the other hand, is New York to its core. A little gritty, a little shady and the person sitting next to you at the counter might be a genius or fucking crazy. The bacon, egg and cheese sandwich is the second best in Park Slope (after the minuscule place next to Besso, which by the way, is a front for a totally insane sex club in the basement).
Anyway, I was talking to someone about the whole issue tonight over dinner and I realized I haven’t really been in a chain store in a long time.
Which is odd. Because Austin is an auto dependent city, ringed by the strip mall hell that is America. But if you live sort of centrally, you don’t much notice. Books? I go to BookPeople (recently voted the best indie bookstore in the country). Music? Waterloo Records, a truly mesmerizing record store that managed to put a Tower out of business. Clothes? When do I buy clothes? But if I did, the nice boys who run Eco-Wise would be happy to outfit me quite stylishly. Food? Well, okay, with groceries we’re looking at chains, but they’re chains like Whole Foods.
But the great part is that Austin’s unofficial slogan is “Keep Austin Weird.” The slogan itself is annoying. But it grew out of a grassroots effort to stop a Border’s store from being built within blocks of the existing BookPeople and Waterloo. It’s underlying philosophy has been to support local business in the face of national chains. And it’s become part of the city’s
official economic development plan. Any “big boxes” that want to come here go to the already existing concrete and asphalt sprawl that rings the town. That Borders? It got built north of town, in the land of sprawl. The city government is committed to maintaining a unique, locally run commercial district and that’s, frankly, stunning.
My nearly ten years in New York saw a lot of that city’s character stripped away in the name of economic growth. Times Square, to cite one over cited example, became Disney: NYC; SoHo became the World’s Largest Mall For Rich People. But, one of the things I loved about Park Slope was that even as the cost of housing went into the stratosphere, a place like Snooky’s still had a customer base and we didn’t have a Gap. That kind of energy is part of what drew me to Austin in the first place. And while I’m sure there’s a D&D or Krispy Kreme out one of the highways, I can pretend they don’t exist, because they’re just not opening next door to Mi Madres where I get my café con leche and breakfast tacos.